Broken links can take visitors to error pages and disrupt how search engines discover your website content. As the number of pages grows, checking every link manually is no longer practical. Using the right broken link checker tools for websites helps businesses identify issues faster and plan a systematic response.
Crawlers, browser extensions, and Google Search Console can all help check links, but each method has a different scope and workflow. This article explores the advantages and limitations of each option and suggests a process for finding errors accurately without wasting resources.
What Are Broken Links, and Why Should You Check Them?
A broken link is a URL that no longer takes users to the content they expect. When clicked, it may show a 404 error, a server error, an inaccessible-page message, or redirect to an unrelated page. The problem may affect internal links between pages on your website or external links pointing to another domain.

A link is not always completely broken. A page may respond slowly, require a login, be blocked by server settings, or redirect through multiple URLs. Before making changes, distinguish temporary connection issues from URLs that are genuinely no longer working.
Regular checks support both the user experience and SEO operations. Visitors are less likely to get stuck on error pages, and search bots can continue discovering important pages. However, a few broken links do not automatically mean a website will lose rankings. Prioritize issues based on their volume, link placement, page importance, and potential effect on conversions.
- Internal links: Can disrupt navigation to categories, articles, service pages, or conversion pages.
- External links: Can lead to reference sources that have been removed, moved, or taken offline.
- Images and resources: Broken image, download, or embedded-resource URLs can leave pages missing content.
Three Common Ways to Find Broken Links
1. Use a Crawler to Scan the Entire Website
A crawler is software that automatically follows links across a website, starting from one or more seed URLs and collecting data according to its settings. It typically reports HTTP response codes, the source URL containing a broken link, the resource type, and sometimes the redirect path. This approach is useful for auditing websites with many pages or exporting reports for content and technical teams.

A crawler’s main advantage is its ability to check a large number of pages, run on a schedule, and provide data that can be filtered and categorized. In a single scan, a site administrator can find 404 pages, incorrect internal links, and resources that fail to load. Some tools also let users set page limits, crawl speed, domain scope, and URL types to exclude.
On the other hand, crawlers need to be configured correctly and can take time to run on large websites. If a website requires a login, blocks bots, loads content with JavaScript, or limits request rates, results may be incomplete or inaccurate. A crawler also typically shows only that a URL did not respond as expected; someone still needs to verify the cause and decide how to address it.
2. Use an Extension for a Quick Check
A link-checking extension works right in the browser. Users open a page, run the extension, and see links marked by status, such as working, redirected, or broken. This is a convenient option for an editor checking a new article, reviewing a landing page before publication, or verifying a small group of links.
Extensions are quick to start with and simple to use: there is no need to configure a crawl project or export a large dataset. However, their scope is usually limited to the open page or the content the browser can load. To review an entire website, users must check pages individually or use another tool. Results may also be affected by blocked extensions, login sessions, internal networks, or temporary issues with the destination website.
3. Use Google Search Console
Google Search Console (GSC) provides data on how Google crawls and indexes a website. Its Page Indexing report can help identify URLs that are not indexed, including cases involving server errors or pages that cannot be found. GSC is useful when a business wants to understand what Google is encountering, rather than simply check a link’s status at a particular moment.
GSC is not a tool for scanning every link on a page on demand. Its reports depend on data Google has collected, so they may not reflect a new website issue immediately. A URL that is not indexed is not necessarily a broken link; the page may have a noindex tag, duplicate content, a crawl block, or may not yet have been discovered by Google. Read the reason shown in the report and check the website directly.
For broader SEO monitoring, LilyTech often recommends combining GSC data with direct checks rather than treating a single report as the final verdict. This approach helps distinguish problems affecting users from issues related only to crawling or indexing.
Comparing Crawlers, Extensions, and Google Search Console
No single method works best in every situation. Choose based on the scope you need to check, how often you need to do it, and the skills of the person carrying out the review. The list below summarizes the main differences:

- Crawler: Best for checking many pages, building an error list, and monitoring on a schedule. It requires crawl-scope configuration and may face limitations on large or protected websites.
- Extension: Best for quickly reviewing one page or checking content before publication. It is easy to use but not ideal for auditing an entire website.
- Google Search Console: Best for monitoring how Google crawls and indexes a website and identifying issues with URLs. Data may be delayed, and GSC does not replace a full link scan.
If you need to answer, “Which pages on the website contain broken links?”, a crawler is usually the most direct option. If you are editing a specific page, an extension can help you check it quickly. If you want to know, “What issues is Google encountering when accessing this URL?”, review GSC and verify the URL using other methods.
For a small website, you can start with an extension and GSC. Websites with hundreds or thousands of URLs should schedule regular crawls, then use GSC to monitor issues affecting crawling and indexing. For e-commerce sites or websites that are updated frequently, combining all three methods provides broader coverage.
How to Check and Prioritize Issues
An effective check involves more than exporting a list of broken URLs. You need to identify where each issue occurs, how much it matters, and what action to take. The following process works for business websites of different sizes:

- Define the scope: Choose the domain, page groups, resource types, and time of the check. If your website has a staging environment, avoid confusing test data with the live website.
- Run the checks: Use a crawler for broad coverage, an extension to verify specific pages, and GSC to review URLs flagged by Google.
- Categorize the results: Separate internal links, external links, missing resources, 404 errors, server errors, and redirects. Record the source URL, destination URL, and response code where available.
- Verify manually: Open the URL in a browser or check it again after some time. This helps rule out network errors, access restrictions, and temporary issues.
- Prioritize by impact: Address errors on high-traffic pages, service and product pages, forms, and pages with important internal links first. An external link in an old article is usually less urgent than a broken link in the checkout process.
- Fix and recheck: After making changes, rerun the tool on the relevant scope to confirm the new URL works and has not created an additional redirect chain.
Save reports from before and after the fixes to track trends. If the same groups of pages keep generating errors, the root cause may lie in the publishing process, URL structure changes, or how discontinued products are managed—not just in individual links.
How to Fix Broken Links After Finding Them
Choose a solution based on whether the destination content still exists. If the URL was entered incorrectly but the page is still available, update the link to the correct address. If the page has moved to a new URL and the content is equivalent, update internal links and consider a 301 redirect from the old URL to help users and traffic sources that still use the old address.

If the content has been removed and there is no suitable replacement, delete the link or replace it with another reliable source. Avoid redirecting every broken URL to the homepage: users may not find the content they expected, and search engines may struggle to understand the relationship between the old page and the destination. A useful 404 page should clearly explain that the content is no longer available and suggest a relevant category or resource.
For server errors or timeouts, check again before changing the URL. Contact the technical team if the issue recurs, especially when multiple pages return errors. After fixing the issue, review the link on the source page, the destination URL’s response status, and the GSC report if the error is related to Google’s crawling process.
Conclusion
Crawlers, extensions, and Google Search Console each play a different role in finding broken links. Crawlers are suited to large-scale reviews, extensions support quick checks on individual pages, and GSC shows what Google reports during crawling and indexing. Combining the right broken link checker tools for websites with verification and impact-based prioritization helps businesses resolve issues effectively instead of simply working through a list of URLs.
If your website has a complex structure, recurring errors, or needs technical checks integrated with an overall SEO strategy, contact LilyTech for advice on the right approach. Our team can assess your website and recommend a process to improve both the user experience and digital operations.
Đoàn Lê Minh Anh