When users visit a web address and can’t find the content, they often see a “404 Not Found” message. For website owners and marketers, the question “What is a 404 error in SEO?” is about more than an error message. It also involves customer experience, search engine crawling, and SEO performance.
A 404 error doesn’t mean Google will penalize a website or immediately lower its rankings. However, if an important page returns an error, many valueless URLs remain widely linked, or users repeatedly hit dead ends, a website can lose traffic and conversion opportunities. This article will help you identify the cause and choose the right solution: fix the page, redirect it, or keep the 404 status code.
What Is a 404? How It Differs from Other Status Codes
404 is an HTTP status code indicating that the server received and processed a request but couldn’t find the resource at the requested URL. In simple terms, the browser connected to the website, but the specific page doesn’t exist at that address. A 404 page may appear because content was deleted, a URL was entered incorrectly, the URL structure changed, or a link points to the wrong page.

One important SEO consideration is the difference between a 404 response code and the design of an error page. A website can create a branded, user-friendly 404 page with a search bar or helpful content recommendations. But if the page still returns a 404 status code, search engines will understand that the URL has no valid content. Conversely, a page that looks like an error page but returns a 200 status code can create a “soft 404”—a mismatch between the content and the response code.
- 404 Not Found: The requested resource cannot be found at the URL. This may be temporary or permanent.
- 410 Gone: The resource has been deleted, and the website owner confirms it won’t be restored.
- 301 Moved Permanently: The URL has been permanently moved to a relevant new address.
- 200 OK: The server indicates that the content was delivered successfully. Don’t use this code for a page that doesn’t actually exist.
How Do 404 Errors Affect SEO?
Not every 404 error harms rankings. URLs that never had content, mistyped URLs, or old pages with no remaining demand can normally return a 404. Google needs to know when a page no longer exists so it can stop indexing that URL. So don’t rush to redirect every 404 page to the homepage just to “clear the error.”
The SEO impact that deserves attention usually occurs when a valuable page returns an error or a website handles its status incorrectly. If an article receives organic traffic, has quality backlinks, or ranks for important keywords but suddenly returns a 404, users and search engines can no longer access it. Traffic, conversions, and the value of links pointing to that URL may be affected.
At scale, large numbers of broken URLs caused by a website migration, category structure changes, or incorrect internal links can waste crawl time. However, Googlebot visiting a 404 URL doesn’t automatically mean that a website will be penalized or that its crawl budget will be seriously affected. Prioritize issues based on the number of URLs, page importance, traffic sources, and inbound links.
404 errors can also cause indirect harm. Users looking for a product, information, or service may leave the website if they see nothing but a blunt error message. Bounce rate and time on page aren’t simple ranking factors where “higher is always better,” but a poor experience can still make users less likely to explore the website or complete a purchase.
How to Find and Classify 404 URLs
Before fixing errors, determine which URLs actually need attention. A long list of alerts doesn’t mean every URL is equally important. Combine data from Google Search Console, website analytics, your content management system, server logs, and link-checking tools to understand where the errors are coming from.

- Check indexing reports: Review URLs that aren’t indexed, when Google found them, and any URL patterns that suggest widespread errors.
- Crawl the website: Use a crawling tool to find internal links pointing to 404 pages and verify the actual status codes returned by those URLs.
- Compare traffic and conversions: Prioritize pages that previously received organic traffic, orders, leads, or significant engagement.
- Check backlinks: URLs with links from reputable websites or widespread shares are worth considering for restoration or an appropriate redirect.
- Identify the cause: Distinguish between an incorrectly entered URL, a broken internal link, a structural change, deleted content, or a server configuration issue.
After classifying the URLs, create a table that lists each broken URL, its cause, its SEO value, a replacement page if available, the proposed action, and the person responsible. This approach helps teams avoid making arbitrary fixes and makes it easier to verify the results after implementation.
Should You Fix, Redirect, or Keep a 404 Page?
Restore the Content When the Page Still Has Value
If a URL returns an error because content was deleted by mistake, there was a server issue, the configuration is incorrect, or the URL changed unexpectedly, restore the content at the old URL if possible. This is often the right approach if the page still has search demand, backlinks, or strong conversion data. If the content still exists but an internal link uses the wrong URL, update the link to point directly to the correct address.
Use a 301 Redirect When There’s an Equivalent Replacement Page
A 301 redirect is appropriate when a page has been replaced with new content on a similar topic that serves the same purpose, or when the URL structure has changed permanently. For example, a guide moves to a new URL but keeps its content and meets the same search need. Update internal links, the sitemap, and related materials to point directly to the new URL rather than relying on the redirect indefinitely.
Don’t redirect every broken URL to the homepage, a general category page, or unrelated content. Users may not find what they expected, and search engines may consider the redirect irrelevant. If there’s no genuinely equivalent replacement page, leaving the URL to return a 404 or 410 is usually more transparent.
Keep the 404 Code or Return a 410 When the Content Has No Further Value
Keep the 404 status code if a URL no longer exists and you don’t need to confirm that its removal is permanent. Use 410 when content has been deliberately removed and won’t return, such as a promotion that has ended with no suitable replacement page. In either case, the error page should help users move forward by offering a search box, links to relevant categories, popular content, or a way to return to the previous page.
If a product is out of stock but may be restocked, consider keeping the page and displaying its availability, alternative products, and an option to receive a notification. If a product has been discontinued, you can keep the page if it remains useful—for example, by providing specifications, support documentation, or recommendations for a successor product. Base the decision on user needs and the page’s actual value, not just whether the URL currently returns an error.
A 404 Error Resolution Process to Help Protect Rankings
A consistent process helps teams address the right issues and avoid creating new ones. You can follow these steps:

- Prioritize important URLs: Address pages with organic traffic, rankings, conversions, or quality backlinks first.
- Choose an action that fits the purpose: Restore the content, fix the link, redirect with a 301 to an equivalent page, or keep the 404/410 if there’s no replacement content.
- Verify the response code: Use an HTTP status checker to confirm that each URL returns the intended 200, 301, 404, or 410 code. Avoid redirect chains and soft 404s.
- Update internal signals: Fix links in articles, menus, category pages, XML sitemaps, and structured data where relevant.
- Check after implementation: Crawl the website again, review Search Console reports, and monitor traffic, conversions, and indexing status.
To prevent future errors, establish a process for deleting or changing URLs: assess the page’s value, identify a replacement page, update links, and test changes in a staging environment before launch. After every website redesign or structural change, crawl all important URLs and verify redirects.
Conclusion: Handle 404 Errors Correctly to Protect User Experience and SEO
Understanding what a 404 error in SEO is helps businesses avoid two extremes: ignoring every broken page or redirecting everything to the homepage. Assess each URL based on its cause, content value, traffic, backlinks, and how relevant any replacement page is. Restore pages that still have value, use a 301 when equivalent content is available, and keep a 404 or 410 when the resource is genuinely gone.
If your website has many broken URLs, has recently changed its structure, or needs a technical SEO audit, LilyTech can help assess its current state and recommend an appropriate action plan. Contact LilyTech for advice on optimizing your website, improving user experience, and protecting your business’s organic search performance.
